by TheNesta » Tue Jun 12, 2012 1:52 am
Atelier
The Atelier series has been around forever, and my first exposure with it was I think Iris 2 on PS2. For whatever reason it didn't hold me that long though (I think I would enjoy going back to it now though). Later I tried Atelier Rorona the first in the Arland trilogy (the first three PS3 games) and was disheartened to find that I wasn't gelling with it either. Really unfortunate with that one, because like you I thought the game looked gorgeous. I remember Roll was watching me play it and we were both like "Man, I wish this game was better, it looks so good." (Again, I think I'd enjoy going back to it).
Anyways, for whatever reason I decided to go full-in with Atelier Totori, and ended up buying it when it came out. And I fell in absolute love with it. I can only really speak to the three Arland games, but they are just a refreshingly new take on JRPGs.
Basically, there is a small plot that progresses you through the game, but it's mostly just lighthearted. There's never a situation where you have to save the world, there isn't even a villain. It's just a lighthearted adventure that let's the characters build up friendships and roam around the world doing various things. Don't get me wrong, I love the big epic stories, but this was just something new, and interesting for me.
The majority of the games you are juggling a few different tasks. Exploring, Crafting, and trying to meet the requirements to keep the story going. There is an in-game time limit to things, but it still feels like a relaxing experience overall.
Most of the characters are well written, and there's a lot of cute and funny dialog between them. The localization is good too, but even if you don't like the dub (which I think is great), you can play with the original Japanese dub. And as has been mentioned the games just look beautiful, with super cute character designs.
I really recommend checking it out if you like JRPGs, and are maybe looking for something a little more lighthearted and fun. Both Totori, and Meruru will have taken spots on my Games of The Year lists for 2011, and 2012 respectively.
Ar Tonelico
You're right about Ar Tonelico, it is a bit of a spin-off, made by the same studio, Gust. Like Atelier, there is a major emphasis on crafting, or synthesis as they call it in these games. However Ar Tonelico is structured more like a traditional JRPG, with an epic story, deeper combat systems, and interestingly enough, a quasi-dating sim aspect to it.
Like Adol, I'm a really huge fan of this series too, and as I think we've discussed on this very forum, the music is absolutely fantastic. Really some of the best game soundtracks out there. And if you're in a position to play Ar Tonelico 2, I highly suggest it, because it's easily the best game in the series, and perhaps one of my favorite JRPGs.
As for the other two games. Ar Tonelico 1 is a fine game, if you play it first there's a few callbacks to it that fans will appreciate. And Ar Tonelico 3 is... well, it's alright. It has problems, but I still enjoyed it.
Last two things. The HDTV thing that Adol mentioned is interesting. I don't recall having that problem, but it did take me a long time to figure out the battle system... so... I'm not sure. I will say that I've only played the game on a backwards compatible PS3 w/ HDMI. Though that had it's own complications, as I got corrupted save data a lot, and I think other people had that problem too.
Final thing. Ar Tonelico is very fanservicey, lots of cheesecake and innuendo. Personally I enjoy that stuff, but I thought it bared mentioning. Where as Atelier is almost entirely innocent.
Ys
I've tried playing some Ys lately, but the platforming is difficult for me (I am really, really, really, super, terrible at platforming) so I got to a point in OiF where I just couldn't deal with it anymore. It's really disappointing because I was diggin' the game otherwise. So, I guess I'm wondering if either Ys VII or the new Origins games that just came out on Steam are lighter on platforming or not.