Preface: Not my rant. Someone else's. But you know what? It sums up my feelings about the word tranny, so I wanted to share it with you guys.
-------------------
Tranny has many meanings. From the transmission in a car, to a transistor radio, the word was used as slang to a number of words which start with trans-. But those meanings aren't what make me hate the word, they're just distractions. No, we all know why tranny is hated by people like myself. Tranny is one of the most common slang words for transsexual and transgender people. Most trans people consider the word to be pretty offensive, especially when it's used by anyone who is not trans. With good reason, of course. This word brings with it the worst of societies stereotypes about trans people. It's used to isolate trans people, to separate them from "normal" people. It's used to comment on someone's appearance, to say they just look wrong. It's used as a way to talk about trans sex workers and trans porn actors, as a way to minimize us to a single aspect of who we are. When someone says tranny, there is a huge bucket of fucked up meanings which come along with the word.
But, we all know that. Every trans person I know has encountered the word, whether it's used hatefully toward them or not. Celebrities, especially from the Gay and Lesbian community, often use it, whether they mean to hurt trans people or not. They use it to refer to drag queens, or to people who just don't fit. They sling the word out whenever they feel the need to hurt people for their appearance, or for how they don't fit in. The trans community has dealt with it for years now, and we're getting really good at calling people on their shit around this word. No, it's not ok to call your friend a hot tranny mess, even if you mean it endearingly. It isn't ok to talk about trannies when referring to porn, even if that's what ignorant people call porn including trans people. No, it's not ok to talk about trannies as if they are some fictional construct, like you see in movies, and it certainly isn't ok to refer to a trans woman as a tranny, even if she "stole your boyfriend" and you were angry. A lot of people get it, a lot of people ignore it, and still others defend themselves, as if they have some inalienable right to use offensive language without being criticized.
I still hate the word. I hate when it's used with hatred against trans people, and I hate when it's used with ignorance about trans people. I hate how when gay and lesbian people say it, it turns into a big fight between some trans people saying "Uh, please don't say that, it's really not cool" and some of the gay and lesbian community saying that it's ok, because of some new excuse of the week. It happens every time. I hate how there are people who claim to be allies, but who don't actually defend trans people when they slurs are used against them. But, what I hate most is when trans people say tranny, and other trans people get angry.
Honestly, there's a lot more to the argument then just a word. The word is just a convenient proxy for the real argument that's tearing up the trans community. Currently, in the trans community, and especially in the GLBT, and queer community at large, trans masculinity is valued much more than trans femininity. So, there's an element of privilege involved in the interactions between the feminine trans people and the masculine trans people, and part of this privilege is the usage of the word tranny. When a trans masculine person uses the word tranny, in an attempt to reclaim the word, it can harm trans feminine people. But why?
In one sense, the word tranny belongs to all trans people, no matter what gender they identify with. It's used with equal malice against trans men as it is against trans women. If someone is shouting tranny at you, the person who is shouting doesn't care if you look masculine or feminine. If they are keeping trannies out of the locker rooms, they are keeping trans masculine and trans feminine people out. But, in another very real sense, the word tranny is much more damaging to trans women then it is to trans men. Because of the privilege masculinity holds in our society, people who appear masculine are given more slack, they are accepted more readily. As such, trans men are implicitly accepted more than trans women in our culture, because it's acceptable to be masculine but it's not acceptable to be feminine. It's for this reason, that when most people use the word tranny in the abstract, or when talking about pornography, or when talking about how people look terrible and deviant, they are implicitly referring to trans women, not trans men. Consider the number of trans masculine porn sties out there, compared to trans women sites. If someone says you look like a tranny, most often they are saying they look like a woman who looks like a man. Think about the expressions of trans-ness in society. Trans women are mocked, are trying to trick people, are the people whom bear more of the violence, and who are in the spotlight. When a trans man takes back a word which is often used specifically against trans women, there's a problematic power differential there. Trans women are marginalized in queer communities, and ostracized in society as a whole, and are understandably angry when the marginalization continues.
But, that doesn't mean that trans men who use the word tranny are the same as cis people using the word tranny. Trans men are hurt and marginalized by the slur, even if trans women are often marginalized more. It can be empowering to take a slur which has been used against you, and to use it with strength. Also, trans men are not the reason why femininity is minimized. They are just benefiting from it.
I hate the word tranny. It's ugly. It hurts real people, and it exposes the divisions among trans people. If you want to use the word tranny, remember: not everyone has the same experience with the word that you do, and there are still problems attached to it.
Addendum. Not saying people can or can't use the word. Just saying think about it before you do use it. And, I'm saying that I personally really hate the word.
------------------------
Endquote.
Yeah. It sucks. When people use it in general it sucks. Please don't.
Also, transgender is an adjective. You don't meet a transgender. You meet a transgender person. I'm trans. I'm transgender. I'm a trans woman. I'm not a trans. I'm not a transgender.
Speak the difference. It means a lot to us.
We already go through enough.
Every day I wake up. I look at the mirror and frown. I go downstairs where my parents say, "Good morning son." I cringe. I go to school. The entire school day I feel like people can see into my head and I'm struck with huge anxiety because of the stigma associated with being trans. I go into gym and am forced to play for the boys team. I go to lunch and if I sat next to a girl my friends say it's because I have a crush on her. Not because I could just want to be friends with people who are actual like me. But no... I don't get to be friends with people with similar minds. I'm not the same gender. I go home. I take a shower. I look at my body and am "disgusted." I'm confused. I'm struck with dysphoria. There's a literal definition for it... but there's no way to explain how it feels for your body to not match your mind. Every day my mind grows weaker and I get a little more depressed. I'm haunted by numbers, like the 41% attempted suicide rate of trans women. The 21% unemployment rate of trans women. The possibility that if my parents through me out I'll have to consider prostitution to live. And when I go to bed I can't even cry because social stigma says that men don't cry. Every day of my life. And each day it gets worse and worse. I can fix it... but I need to jump through hoops for therapists telling them what I want to hear before they let me speak to a doctor who can prescribe the necessary hormones to fix me. Even if my body feels right to me, it won't to others. Others will still judge me. I'll still be the butt of jokes. People will look at me in disgust. The chance of me becoming invisible is ridiculously low. And it's not my choice.
The least you could do is use the right words. All transgender people appreciate it. Thanks for listening.